The market for laser engraving machines has become increasingly competitive, with numerous options available to both hobbyists and professionals. Among these, the Onelaser XRF and the xTool P2 stand out as two prominent models, each offering unique features.
However, when comparing the two, it's important to consider key factors such as laser type, performance, speed, material compatibility, and overall value.
In this comparison, we'll break down the differences and similarities between these two machines to help you make an informed decision.
1. Laser Type & Performance
1.1 OneLaser's 38W RF Metal CO₂ laser: For Enhanced Durability and Precision
The Onelaser XRF utilizes a 38W RF Metal CO₂ laser, which is specifically designed for high precision and durability. RF (Radio Frequency) technology enables a highly efficient and consistent laser beam, which is crucial for achieving intricate, fine designs on a variety of materials.
The RF Metal CO₂ laser in the XRF ensures a longer operational life compared to traditional lasers. With its higher energy efficiency, it maintains excellent engraving quality over extended use, making it perfect for businesses and hobbyists who need reliable, consistent results.
Learn more: RF Laser Tube Frequency Tips for Precise Engraving
1.2 xTool P2's 55W Glass Tube CO₂ laser: Shorter Lifespan
In contrast, the P2 employs a 55W Glass Tube CO₂ laser, which provides a higher initial power output compared to the Onelaser XRF. However, Glass Tube lasers have a significantly shorter lifespan than RF lasers.
Typically, a Glass Tube laser can last between 1,000 to 2,000 hours before needing replacement, which may add hidden costs over time. While the P2 can handle more demanding projects in terms of power, the trade-off is the frequency of maintenance and replacement.
1.3 Advantages of RF Technology: Instant start, Longer life, and Better engraving quality
The RF laser in the Onelaser XRF offers several advantages over Glass Tube lasers. RF lasers can start instantly without the warm-up time that glass tube lasers often require, which increases operational efficiency.
Moreover, RF technology provides a much longer service life, often exceeding 10,000 hours of use, reducing the frequency of replacements. Additionally, RF lasers produce cleaner, sharper engravings with improved consistency, ensuring high-quality results even with intricate designs.
Learn more: RF CO2 Laser Vs Glass Tube CO2 laser- Which Better?
2. Speed & Precision
2.1 1,200 mm/s vs. 600 mm/s, It's Not Just Speed
When it comes to speed, the Onelaser XRF is a clear winner, boasting an engraving speed of up to 1,200 mm/s. This speed allows for rapid execution of projects, increasing overall workflow efficiency.
High-speed engraving is particularly beneficial in high-volume production environments, where reducing the time per item can significantly boost output.
The xTool P2, on the other hand, operates at a slower speed of 600 mm/s, which may affect overall production capacity and limit the ability to handle high-demand jobs.
2.2 Impact of high speed on workflow efficiency and production capacity
The faster engraving speed of the Onelaser XRF not only improves workflow efficiency but also reduces the amount of time spent on each individual project. This can directly impact production capacity, making the XRF a more viable option for businesses that rely on quick turnaround times.
Additionally, the increased speed ensures that users can meet deadlines without compromising the quality of the engraving.
2.3 Unmatched engraving precision with RF laser technology
Precision is another critical aspect of laser engraving, and the Onelaser XRF excels here due to its RF Metal CO₂ laser.
The stability and consistency of the RF laser ensure that fine details are captured with unmatched accuracy. This makes the XRF an excellent choice for intricate designs such as logos, fine text, and detailed patterns, where precision is paramount.
3. Work Area & Material Compatibility: Maximizing Versatility
3.1 Onelaser XRF's optimized engraving space for different project sizes
The Onelaser XRF offers a larger and more optimized work area that can handle a variety of project sizes, from small personal items to larger commercial pieces. This versatility makes the XRF ideal for users who work with a wide range of materials and need the flexibility to take on diverse projects.
The machine's expansive engraving space ensures that users can complete large batches or larger workpieces without worrying about space limitations.
3.2 xTool P2's passthrough function—when it's useful and when it's not
One of the notable features of the xTool P2 is its passthrough function, which allows for longer materials to be passed through the machine. While this feature may sound appealing, it's not always the most practical for every project. The passthrough is useful for engraving larger materials or when engraving multiple items in a single pass.
However, this function doesn't offer the same flexibility and space as the larger work area of the Onelaser XRF, which could limit its utility for users working with varied material sizes and shapes.
3.3 Which machine supports a broader range of materials?
The Onelaser XRF supports a broader range of materials, including metals, wood, acrylics, and leather, giving users the flexibility to work on diverse projects. The advanced RF laser allows for high-quality engravings on tougher materials like coated metals, which the xTool P2 may not be able to handle as effectively. This makes the XRF a better option for users who require versatility in material compatibility.
4. Rotary Engraving
4.1 Onelaser XRF's full rotary compatibility for engraving tumblers and cylindrical objects
The Onelaser XRF comes with full rotary compatibility, allowing users to engrave tumblers, bottles, and other cylindrical objects with precision. The rotary attachment ensures that designs are uniformly applied to curved surfaces, which is essential for businesses that offer personalized drinkware or custom promotional items. This feature enhances the machine's ability to support a wide range of product customization.
4.2 xTool P2's lack of rotary support—what it means for businesses
Unlike the XRF, the xTool P2 lacks rotary engraving capabilities. This limitation can be a significant drawback for businesses that specialize in custom cylindrical items such as tumblers, mugs, and bottles.
The inability to offer rotary engraving means that xTool P2 users would have to invest in a separate rotary tool or outsource such work, adding both time and costs to the production process.
4.3 Why rotary engraving is essential for product customization
Rotary engraving is critical for businesses that want to provide personalized products such as engraved tumblers, bottles, or glassware. It ensures a high level of customization and precision on curved surfaces, making it an essential feature for expanding product offerings.
The full rotary capability of the Onelaser XRF makes it an all-in-one solution for those looking to maximize customization potential.
5. Software & Control
5.1 Onelaser XRF's seamless compatibility with LightBurn for industry-standard design control
The Onelaser XRF integrates seamlessly with LightBurn, an industry-standard laser software that offers an extensive set of tools for precise control over designs.
LightBurn allows users to import vector files, create custom designs, and optimize engraving settings with ease. Its intuitive interface and powerful features make it the preferred choice for professionals who demand control and accuracy in their work.
5.2 xTool P2's reliance on proprietary software—limitations and drawbacks
The xTool P2 operates using proprietary software, which may not be as flexible or compatible with other design programs. While the software is functional for basic designs, it lacks the extensive features found in more professional platforms like LightBurn.
The closed nature of xTool's software can limit the types of file formats users can work with and may not offer the same level of customization that professionals expect.
5.3 Why professionals prefer LightBurn's advanced features
LightBurn's advanced features, such as optimized material settings, real-time previewing, and detailed design controls, make it the go-to choice for professional engravers. It offers users the ability to fine-tune every aspect of their project, from speed and power settings to more complex vector manipulations.
This level of control and precision is crucial for professionals who want to achieve flawless results on every project.
Learn more: Best Laser Engraving Software
6. Cooling & Maintenance
6.1 Why RF lasers last longer and offer better long-term value
The durability and long lifespan of RF lasers provide better long-term value. Unlike Glass Tube lasers, which require frequent replacements, RF lasers offer consistent performance over thousands of hours of operation, reducing overall maintenance costs and ensuring a more stable ROI.
6.2 Onelaser XRF's efficient cooling system and reduced maintenance needs
The Onelaser XRF is equipped with a high-efficiency cooling system designed to prevent overheating and extend the lifespan of the machine. This system ensures that the engraver runs smoothly even during long hours of operation, reducing the need for frequent maintenance or repairs. Additionally, RF laser technology is inherently more reliable and requires less upkeep than Glass Tube lasers.
6.3 xTool P2's built-in cooling—how Glass Tube lasers require more upkeep
While the xTool P2 features a built-in cooling system, the maintenance requirements for Glass Tube lasers are more demanding. Glass Tube lasers tend to degrade faster and need regular servicing to maintain optimal performance. This means that businesses relying on the xTool P2 may face higher operational costs in terms of maintenance and downtime, as compared to the more durable and low-maintenance RF technology in the Onelaser XRF.
7. Price & Value
7.1 Cost vs. value: How Onelaser XRF offers premium features at a competitive price
While the Onelaser XRF may come at a higher initial cost compared to the xTool P2, its superior features, durability, and performance provide unmatched value in the long run. When
factoring in reduced maintenance costs, extended laser lifespan, and higher productivity, the Onelaser XRF delivers excellent value for both professionals and businesses.
7.2 The true cost of ownership: RF laser durability vs. frequent tube replacements
The true cost of owning a laser engraver extends beyond the initial purchase price. While the xTool P2 may appear to be a more affordable option upfront, its frequent Glass Tube replacements over time can lead to higher overall costs.
In contrast, the Onelaser XRF's RF laser technology offers superior durability, reducing the need for costly replacements and offering a better long-term investment.
7.3 ROI for businesses: higher efficiency, lower downtime, and long-term savings
For businesses that rely on laser engraving as a revenue stream, the Onelaser XRF presents a more profitable choice in the long run. With faster engraving speeds, better material compatibility, and less frequent maintenance, the XRF minimizes downtime and maximizes productivity. This leads to higher efficiency, greater output, and ultimately, a more significant return on investment.
8. Comparing Table Between XRF VS P2
To sum up, here's a side-by-side comparison of the key features of the Onelaser XRF and xTool P2 laser engravers. This chart highlights the main specifications to help you evaluate which machine best suits your engraving needs, whether you're a professional looking for precision and efficiency or a hobbyist seeking a versatile, cost-effective option.
| Feature | Onelaser XRF | xTool P2 |
| Laser Type | 38W RF Metal CO₂ Laser | 55W Glass Tube CO₂ Laser |
| Max Engraving Speed | 1,200 mm/s | 600 mm/s |
| Positioning Accuracy | ≤0.01 mm | 0.3mm |
| Laser Spot Size | 0.07 mm | / |
| DPI | 2000 | 1000 |
| Work Area | 600mmx300mm(23.6” x 11.8”in) | 600 x 305 mm (23.6 x 12 in) |
| Rotary Compatibility | ✅ Yes (Supports Rotary) | ❌ No (Rotary not supported) |
| Material Thickness (Single Pass Cutting) | 160mm (With Riser Base) | 20 mm acrylic, 18 mm black walnut |
| Passthrough Capability | ✅ Yes (Straight-through Access Up to 160mm with Base Boost Add-On) | ✅ Yes (Auto passthrough up to 96 inches) |
| Camera System | 5M Camera | Dual 16MP Cameras |
| Autofocus | ✅ Yes | ✅ Yes |
| Software Compatibility | LightBurn, Other Industry Software | xTool Creative Space, LightBurn |
| Cooling System | Built-in Cooling System | Built-in Cooling System |
| Price | Competitive pricing for professionals($4195) | Mid-range price, suitable for hobbyists & professionals($3699) |
The XRF and P2 are both exceptional laser engravers, but when it comes to performance, speed, and versatility, the Onelaser XRF outperforms the xTool P2 in several key areas.
With superior laser technology, faster engraving speeds, broader material compatibility, and lower long-term maintenance costs, the Onelaser XRF is the optimal choice for professionals, businesses, and serious hobbyists looking for top-tier engraving results.
For those seeking long-term value and superior performance, investing in the Onelaser XRF is a decision that pays off in both the short and long run.
Learn more: OneLaser’s Role in Revolutionizing Laser Technology
